2/13 Curated News

On January 15th, 2026, Democratic Lawmakers led by Representative Julie Casimiro introduced a bill, eliminating the possibility of life without parole for youth offenders under the age of twenty-one. “It’s time to reexamine life without parole for juvenile offenders,” said North Kingstown Rep. Julie Casimiro. This bill was brought before the legislature just a couple of days prior to the Jan. 19 Manton Avenue Attack, where four juveniles between the ages of 11 and 12 were accused of beating Alfonzo, a 51-year-old man, to death. These juveniles are potentially being charged with murder, and the decision rests in the hands of the judge to determine whether or not they will be waived into adult court, and ultimately tried as adults. This bill focuses on youth offenders who receive harsher sentences due to the nature of their crimes, such as murders involving torture or attacks on law enforcement personnel. This bill only pertains to those individuals who committed murder with one of these seven aggravating factors: prior conviction of serious offense, heinous, cruel or depraved manner, substantial planning and premeditation, grave risk of death to additional persons, vulnerability of the victim, economic gain/murder for hire, or leadership role in a large-scale crime. However, the Manton Avenue attack did not include one of the seven aggravating factors; therefore, this bill does not apply to those offenders. It is still unclear whether Mario’s Law would apply in all situations under this new legislation, no matter the circumstances. Austin Dana, NBC legal analyst, states, “I think regardless of what happens with this legislation, and whether or not they are certified up to Superior Court, Mario’s Law would kick in for them.”  

The Democratic Lawmaker who introduced this bill eliminating youth life without parole sentences in Rhode Island was also involved in Mario’s Law back in 2021. Representative Julie Casimiro spoke on the issue regarding the new bill in comparison to the previous law. “This is completely separate because Mario’s law excluded life without parole,” says Rep. Julie Casimiro. Mario’s Law, also known as the Youthful Offender Act, proposed that any person convicted of an offense committed before their 22nd birthday, except those serving life without parole, are eligible for parole review after already serving 20 years. This comes as a direct result of the case of Mario Monteiro, who was sentenced to two consecutive life sentences at the age of 17 of first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, using a firearm while committing a crime of violence resulting in death, and related assault charges for a 2001 gang-related shooting in Providence, Rhode Island. Upon serving 20 years, Monteiro was up for parole in 2021 and was unanimously granted such. However, the process was delayed by the Department of Corrections, which chose to examine the life sentences separately. Mario’s experiences while serving his sentence motivated him. He has said that seeing these conditions made him want to help change how the system treats people and to support others in becoming better versions of themselves when they return to the community.  Mario’s law allows for those who were convicted and sentenced to life prior to their 22nd birthday, a second chance. This does not apply to life convictions without the possibility of parole, and also touches upon the issue of dual sentencing. However, this new legislation aims to bridge that gap in the system. Similar to Mario’s Law, the bill would recognize that young people have developing brains and a greater capacity for rehabilitation. In creating Mario’s Law, lawmakers cited psychological and neuroscientific research showing that impulse control and decision-making continue to mature into the mid-20s. The law was designed to give individuals sentenced at a young age a second chance through parole review. This new legislation aims to provide all young offenders a second chance to reflect and rebuild, knowing a chance for parole is possible.

Copy-Editor: Rachel Cabral 

Graphic Design: 

Researcher and Reporter: Kayley Dias, Emma O’Neill

Website Manager: Molly Stinchfield